The Hidden Mistakes That Silently Kill MMI Scores (Even When You Think You Did Well)

We've marked thousands of mock MMIs at ProjectDoctor, and here's a reassuring truth: so many brilliant applicants leave stations thinking "that went alright" – only to score a 6/10 because of subtle habits that interviewers notice immediately. The brilliant part? These are completely fixable, and once addressed, they rocket scores into the top band.

You're already ahead of the curve by reading this – most applicants never spot these pitfalls. Let's fix them together.

Mistake 1: Starting with "I feel" or "I think" too often

It can sound hesitant. Instead, state confidently: "Patient autonomy is the overriding principle here because..." You can soften later with personal reflection. People look to doctors for direction, not confusion. You need to instil confidence and assurance in the patients minds.

Mistake 2: Rushing past empathy

We see it constantly – jumping straight to solutions. Pause. Acknowledge the emotion first: "This must be incredibly upsetting for you and your family." It builds instant rapport. Starting your answer like this shows maturity and genuine understanding.

Mistake 3: Sounding robotic or checklist-like

Structure is essential, but deliver it conversationally. Weave in natural phrases; smile where appropriate (especially on Zoom). Don't sound rehearsed, you need to come across as natural and approachable, bring future dr energy. Answer with a level of confidence that you belong.

Mistake 4: Forgetting to check understanding

In communication or data stations, always ask: "Would you like me to explain anything differently?" or "How are you feeling about what I've said?" It shows patient-centred care. Summarising is another great idea.

Mistake 5: Poor non-verbals

Weak eye contact, fidgeting, or flat tone. Practise with a friend over video – it transforms presence. Sit up straight, smile, use hand gestures where necessary.

Mistake 6: Weak follow-up responses

When probed ("But what if...?"), many freeze. Prepare Layer 2 answers in advance. Show depth. The best applicants prepare preparing answers for questions that haven't even been asked yet and answer them in their main body.

We've watched students eliminate these and go from borderline to firm offers. You're part of a community that notices the details others miss. Implement these changes, and watch your scores soar. Anything unclear, worried about something/unsure how to implement these tips? Get in touch and we'll guide you through the process. You got this.